One of the most amazing things about an NCTE conference is
the contact one has with authors. This
conference provided the opportunity to learn from some masters of Young Adult Literature
and non-fiction. Ta-Nehisi Coates stated
in his interview, “I was most effective in school when I could connect it to
something real.” Several of the YA
authors taught the importance of making learning real through their writing
methods and the issues they addressed in fiction. In “Equity and Social Justice: Using Informational
Texts and Literature in Urban and Rural Classrooms to Help Young Readers Become
Informed Advocates and Global Citizens”, Scholastic authors Deborah Hopkinson
and Deborah Wiles with Professor Brian Williams at Georgia State University had
us consider issues of social justice as we learned to “evaluate, process and
communicate information”. These presenters
considered the danger of a single story.
Professor Williams used the story of Rosa Parks asking, “Do we know the
story?” As we pieced together the Parks
story from multiple perspectives: Park’s, the bus drivers, situations in the
community, and associations Parks had, we learned what we choose to leave out
impacts the story. If we leave out that
Parks made an active decision not to get up out of resistance and her work with
the NCAP, we don’t think of the civil rights movement of being strategic. The idea that this was a strategic act,
empowers students.
How can this idea can be used in an AP classroom? Students need to know the value of multiple
perspectives when writing synthesis essays and considering evidence to use for
argumentation. Assign student research on
different issues or occurrences with a perspective in mind. Each student can present their story from the
assigned perspective, then students can synthesize evidence from multiple
perspectives for a combined story.
Students can consider how the perspective impacts the story. If several different topics are shared in
class, students have evidence to mine in the argument essay. This will hone
evaluation and analysis of evidence and provide students with the understanding
of how multiple perspectives interact—a valuable skill for a synthesis essay.
Deborah Wiles writes documentary novels and her current series
is focused on the 1960’s (Countdown and Revolution). While the novels are middle school level, her
research process and synthesis of ideas provides valuable insights for high
school students. She intertwines her story with opinionated biographies, music
playlists, artifacts from the time period such as letters, newspaper clippings,
etc. using Pinterest (https://www.pinterest.com/debbiewiles/)
to organize her research. As Wiles
states, “Everything is a Remix.” This
remix idea is a great way to teach students to synthesize information. Her novel, Countdown deals with propaganda—an excellent way to delve into the
fake news vs. real news issue we have today.
How can this idea be used in an AP classroom? Have students question what is happening in
their world. Next, have them consider
what else is going on in the world at that time. How do the stories intersect? Have students research multiple genres and
organize their research on Pinterest.
Next, they are ready to synthesize the argument about the “story” they selected.
Deborah Hopkinson writes perspectives on history for upper
Elementary and Middle School students. Again, her methods can inform our
students. She tackles issues such as
public health activism through The Great
Trouble as she considers cholera.
She allows history to inform the reader through critical consciousness.
How can this be used in the AP classroom? One of the things I notice the most when
scoring the Argument question at the reading is history miscues made by
students. Hopkinson and the other
presenters argue for students to be academically competent, culturally
competent and have critical consciousness. Assigning students key historical issues
to research from multiple perspectives and sharing them with the class, will
provide a bank of historical evidence for argument questions. After students have assembled the bank,
students can practice using this information in argument prompts.
For more information about the NCTE Annual Conference, visit this link.
No comments:
Post a Comment